NO
verbal/written/sign language
After taking
part of a 15 minute conversation where I was not able to communicate
with them through speaking, sign language, or written words, I
realized how difficult it was to “communicate” with the two
people. To me it was kind of like charades, however, it was much
harder because it was an actual conversation and not just acting out
a specific action. I don't know any sign language except spelling my
name so that was easy to not use that form of communication. Without
using any sign language, written words, or verbal speaking, it made
me noticed how important those are to us.
My partners
were confused on what was going on and they kept telling me to speak
because they had no clue what I was doing, although, they did catch
on and were able to understand some things here and there. They did
not necessarily alter the way they were communicating with me, they
just slowed down and took their time to try and understand what I was
doing. They had a confused look on their face the whole time but
they caught on by the time the 15 minutes were up.
If both my
partners and I came from different cultures, it would have been even
more difficult trying to talk to them through just hand motions, not
even sign language where movements actually represent something. I
feel not all cultures use sign language or use hand motions as much
as me. I use hand motions even when I'm just talking normal because
it puts emphasis on what I'm trying to explain. I feel like the
speaking culture has the advantage because they can use emotion and
symbols with the hands compared to the culture that doesn't have
symbolic language. The speaking culture could be getting annoyed how
the other culture isn't understanding what they are saying. It would
be extremely difficult for other languages to comprehend what we are
saying because we are used to the way we communicate, unlike them.
In our culture, there are people who have lost their hearing and are
deaf. I had a boy in my class last semester in English who had to
have a person with him every class in order to tell him what his
teacher is saying. The interpreter used sign language to communicate
with the boy in order for him to know what to do. Obviously he was
able to read, so if a paper was handed out, he could understand that,
however, if he was confused, it's not like he could walk up to the
teacher and ask what to do. The interpreter was a huge help and I
give her props because I want to learn sign language and after
watching her do all the symbols was interesting.
Verbal
Communication ONLY
This
was also a difficult task to complete. I tried my best to use only
one tone of voice. The tone of voice can be a dead give away of the
information being said. It uses a lot of emotion because if you're
mad, you would obviously yell, if you were sad, you would cry.
Raising your voice is the beginning of noticing someone's mad when
talking to you. No symbols or sign language made it difficult to put
emphasis on what is being said. I use hand motions in general so it
was really hard for me. One tone of voice is so boring to talk in,
in my opinion. It makes people a boring person and it is something
that I do not choose to do again. Haha.
In
this part of the experiment, my partners were like “okay what is
going on with you now? Have a heart, show some emotion!” I did
not warn them what I was going to do, I just kind of joined their
conversation uninvited. It was just my mom and my dad so no big
deal. My parents were affected as much as the first part of this
assignment because I was able to use verbal language. I can tell
them stuff but I was just a boring person talking, that's all that
was different then talking normal.
Our
signs in our language is very important and we just don't know it.
Symbols are used in every day life and no one notices it because they
don't think they are portraying symbols in any way. Hand motions are
an example of symbols. We all use them but we don't think we're
moving our hands when we're talking.
Children,
I feel have a difficulty of reading body language and the elderly
also. I work with children so I can definitely see them not
understanding the body language I use when talking to them. I will
try to not saying anything and use my arms and hands to tell a child
something if it's too loud in the room. Most of the time they just
yell “WHAT?” At that point, I will call them over to me and
explain what I was saying. When it comes to the elderly, I can see
this also because my grandpa lives with us. He is only 62 years old,
however, he has Alzheimer’s. I will joke with him a lot and he
will joke back, but a lot of them time he won't understand what I am
doing or saying to him. He will also just like the kids say “what?”
but he won't yell it like them. It's sad because my grandpa will
probably never again be able to talk to use like he did when I was
little, but when it comes to the children at work, they will grow up
to learn the different ways people communicate using body language.
Hi Kylie,
ReplyDeleteI really enjoyed reading your post. It is clear and easy to follow. I totally felt like I was playing charades too. You are right, we take the signs in our language for granted. I agree with pretty much everything you said and I like that you did not tell your parents ahead of time and just made them figure it out! Great job! :)
That's interesting that you didn't tell your parents about the experiment beforehand. I'm sure that made your conversation a lot more confusing for them! I definitely thought the first experiment was much more difficult too, at least in the second one we could verbally communicate.
ReplyDeleteIt was very brave of you to do this without explaining to your partners the experiment ahead of time, but it does allow you to get more accurate responses, I believe. Great descriptions.
ReplyDeleteI appreciate your real-life experiences being applied to this experiment. Good connections.
Students often translate the response of their partners in Part 2 into them being 'bored" with the conversation, but keep in mind what we use body language for. It is kind of like a lie detector. Humans use body language to confirm what the spoken message. If they don't match up, humans are less likely to believe what is being said. So if you have NO body language and no way to check the spoken information, people actually become very uncomfortable and try to get out of the conversation. I've had students whose partners became angry or walked off in a huff, all because of the lack of sign language. It is important to recognize just what this says about the value of sign language in communication.
Actually, children are quite adept at reading body language. It is the first language babies learn and they can detect "fakers" without any problem at all (perhaps the kids just don't want to turn down the music? My son does that to me, too!). Older individuals might be a possibility, but there may be other factors involved, such as difficulty seeing or hearing or memory issues that interfere with reading body language. What about people with autism? They are characterized by an inability to read body language. That is why they have such difficulty detecting sarcasm or understanding a joke.
Missed the last point? Can you think of a situation where it might be best to not read body language, to perhaps ignore it? Is there a situation where body language might lie to you? Do all cultures use the same system of body language?
Other than this last point, good post.
Hey Kylie,
ReplyDeleteIts to funny you didn't tell your partner what you were doing. Could you imagine going to Starbucks and trying to order a coffee? I would love to see their reaction. I feel like in experiment one we got similar results both our partners trying to slow down and understand what in the world we are saying!
For working with children i disagree with children not fully understanding body language. But i totally understand the situation your talking about. Often if the room is to loud the child is experiencing over stimulus and can't concentrate fully on you.
Great Post!
Hey Kylie,
ReplyDeleteI totally thought about not letting my partners know about the experiment but I thought it would prove to be even more difficult and I guess Im not as brave as you ;) your blog was very descriptive and kept my interest, not boring at all! I also put that I thought children would not be able to read body language as easily as adults but as Professor Rodriguez said, it's the first language they really learn which makes complete sense. But I understood what you mean. Great job!!
Kylie, your post is really different and very interesting. However, I agree with professor Rodriguez that children are quite adept to read body language because before they get to know how to speak, they would tell you what they want by their body language such as if they're trying to tell you that they want their toy they would act how they play with it or what they do with it and this is a sign that kids understand body language and they learn from you and they can apply it when they need something.
ReplyDelete